Episode 5

full
Published on:

19th Sep 2025

Judy at Carnegie Hall - Judy's "Victory Lap"

Judy at Carnegie Hall - Judy's Victory Lap

In the fifth episode of Judy at Carnegie Hall, your host Grace gets into what's often called Judy's "Victory Lap" of the performance at Carnegie Hall.

Judy takes us on a complete journey from playful nostalgia to sincere connection to pure celebration. To solemn promise to gentle benediction. Oh, each song serves the whole creating a sequence that feels both carefully planned and completely spontaneous at the same time. That's what makes it magic.

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 

Hey Judy Loving Friends! It's me, Grace! I just want to thank you for listening. I hope you’ll let me know what you think about the podcast and if any particular episodes resonate with you. 

Listed just below here is my contact information and the social channels where you can find me.

My Contact Info

Grace Taylor Segal

Email: grace@gracetaylorsegal.com

Facebook: Judy at Carnegie Hall Page here

Instagram: @judyatch_pod here

Judy at Carnegie Hall Podcast Website here

Please leave a review if you like the show!

On Apple Podcasts (here are the steps)

  • Open the Apple Podcasts app. 
  • Search for the podcast you want to review. 
  • Select the podcast show page (not an individual episode). 
  • Scroll to the bottom of the page. 
  • Click "Write a Review". 

Thank you so much for taking the time to review the show!

See you on the next episode of Judy at Carnegie Hall...

Timestamps

00:00 Introduction to Judy at Carnegie Hall

34:59 Suwanee: A Gershwin Classic

35:31 After You've Gone: A Breakup Lament

35:59 Chicago: Judy Lifts the Roof

36:55 The Transcendent Finale

37:52 Closing Remarks and Next Episode Preview

Transcript

Judy at Carnegie Hall_S1_Ep5

[:

Judy's Victory Lap section, big shoulder showbiz, rye optimism, open-hearted devotion, five songs that showcase five different facets. Five different facets of a legend in full command of her powers. This is where Judy proves something that her [00:01:00] detractors never understood. She wasn't just a tragic figure singing through her pain.

She was also a. Entertainer who could light up a room with pure joy, a vaudeville veteran who understood that sometimes the greatest gift you can give an audience is uncomplicated, fun. But being Judy, even her joy comes with depth. Even her entertainment carries emotional weight. What makes this section so powerful is how it demonstrates her range, not just vocally.

n without losing an ounce of [:

Now, this could have been a straightforward crowd pleaser, a safe choice designed to get people, you know, clapping along, but Judy being Judy. She turns it into something far more delicious, a kind of comic vora performance with a wink that lets everyone in on the joke. The crowd roars at her famous send up, and I never will forget Jeanette McDonald.

I had [:

But here's what makes this. This moment brilliant. It shows Judy's relationship with her own MGM past. She's not bitter about those years or trying to distance herself from them more like instead she is reclaiming that history on her own terms, showing that she can honor the tradition while making it entirely her own.

The [:

Next comes. I can't give you anything but love from the 1928 review, blackbirds, and this becomes something entirely different. A warm handout from the stage, an intimate gift wrapped in a simple melody written by j. Written by Jimmy McHugh and Dorothy Fields during the height of the jazz age. This song has been covered by everyone from Louis Armstrong to Billy Holiday.

Judy finds her own truth in [:

Transcends commerce and becomes communion. This is a garland credo in its purest form. I can't give you anything but love, not promises of happiness, not guarantees of easy answers. Just love in the form of music, honestly delivered. In this context of everything she'd been through, everything the audience knew about her struggles.

comes not just a song, but a [:

Then we get that's entertainment from the bandwagon and suddenly we're in entirely different territory. This is Judy embodying the very. Theme of show business. The show must alight, it must live spirits. It must transform ordinary moments into something magical and the show must go on. She tosses the lyric like confetti, each phrase a celebration of the theatrical life she's chosen and the joy it can bring.

The band [:

She's not performing for them. She's celebrating with them, and yet, and this is crucial. She's also the rare artist who makes entertainment feel like, again, communion lesser performance might make the song feel hollow or even calculating. Judy makes it [00:08:00] feel like a shared celebration of everything that makes live performance magical.

This is showbiz at its most honest and generous, performed by someone who understands both. Its superficiality and its profound power to heal and unite. Incredible. Come, Rainer, come, shine follows, and now we're back in deeper emotional territory. This Harold Arlen and Johnny Mercer. Vow song takes on a special meeting at this point in the evening after everything, the intimate confessions, the playful entertainment, the vulnerable moments, this plays like a promise to the audience through every storm, through every high and low.

ere. She stretches the title [:

It's not just about showing up when you feel good or when everything's going well. It's about being there come rain or come shine in sickness and in health through triumph and disaster. Peaks and valleys right. The arrangement builds gradually allowing Judy to demonstrate her vocal power while never losing sight of the song's emotional core [00:10:00] by the time she reaches the final.

I'll be loving you always. It doesn't sound like a romantic promise. It sounds like a sacred vow. Finally, we reach your nearer. Rogers and Hearts Satin Whisper that closes this section with Hush and grace. After all the energy, the emotion that we've experienced with her, this feels like a benediction, a gentle descent.

es the most powerful moments [:

This song serves as a perfect bridge between the celebratory energy we've just experienced, and whatever emotional journey lies ahead, it's. Judy Garland at her most graceful, showing that she can be just as compelling when she whispers as when she belts. The genius of this entire section lies in its emotional architecture.

s both carefully planned and [:

Into something larger than the sum of just their parts. If you're enjoying this deep dive, please subscribe and leave a review. Helps the keep this series visible for. New and longtime Judy Garland fans. My contact details are in the show notes and I'd love to hear from you. Tell me which of these five songs you put on repeat and why.

sonate most deeply with you. [:

Listen for free

Show artwork for Judy at Carnegie Hall

About the Podcast

Judy at Carnegie Hall
Everything You Ever Wanted to Know about the Greatest Concert that Ever Was
If you’re a fan of Judy Garland, music history, or just want to learn about one of the most iconic performances of all time, this podcast is for you. Judy at Carnegie Hall - Everything You Ever Wanted to Know about the Greatest Concert that Ever Was takes you on a deep dive into Judy Garland’s legendary 1961 Carnegie Hall concert—a night that has been called the "greatest night in showbiz history."
As a lifelong Judy Garland fan like so many of you, I can’t wait to share everything I know and love and have learned about this concert with you. From the build-up to that fateful night, the emotional journey Garland took to get to that stage, to the incredible setlist that still gives me chills—this podcast unpacks it all. Every song, every story, and every behind-the-scenes moment will be covered in detail, with each episode taking you further into the magic that made this concert so unforgettable.
What can you expect?
Setting the Stage: We’ll start with the background—why was this concert such a pivotal moment for Judy? What was happening in her career leading up to it?
The Lead-Up: I’ll dig into the planning and prep, including all the key players behind the scenes.
The Setlist Breakdown: In two parts, we’ll dive deep into the songs Judy sang that night, exploring what made her performances so iconic and emotionally powerful.
The Musicians Behind the Magic: Meet the incredible orchestra and music director Mort Lindsey, who helped bring Judy’s performance to life.
The Audience and Atmosphere: Who was in the crowd that night? What was the energy like in Carnegie Hall? I’ve got stories and quotes from those who were there!
Judy's Emotional Performance: We’ll talk about how Judy connected with the audience and how her personal struggles shone through in her performance.
The Legendary Recording: You’ll get an inside look at the process of recording the live album, the challenges, and its massive success afterward.
The Lasting Impact: How did this concert change Judy’s career? What is its legacy in music history?
Whether you’re a die-hard Judy fan or just discovering her brilliance, this podcast will give you a richer appreciation for the woman and her incredible artistry.
I’d sure love for you to be part of this conversation! You can find me on Instagram where I share podcast updates, behind-the-scenes info, and more content about Judy herself, of course. If you have any stories or questions about Judy or the concert, reach out! I’d love to feature listener feedback and insights in upcoming episodes.
So, why listen? You’ll laugh, you’ll cry, and you’ll experience Judy’s monumental night in all its glory. By the end of this podcast, you’ll know every detail about Judy at Carnegie Hall—a concert that, more than 60 years later, still leaves me in awe. Whether you’re a lifelong fan or new to Judy’s world, this is a show that will do its best to bring Judy's magic to life for you.
Join me in celebrating one of the greatest artists of all time—and the night she gave a performance for the ages.
Cue the orchestra! Curtain up!

About your host

Profile picture for Grace Segal

Grace Segal